Learning Maya's Animation System
polycounter lvl 18
Hey guys, very long time no see. I've recovered from a pretty bad case of RSI and recently started learning maya. So far I'm liking it, not better or worse than max, but rigging-wise it's hard getting used to. I've already found out most of these differences are mainly because the terminology is different in maya than it is in max, which makes searching the helpfiles or internet harder for anything specific.
Here is the model I created t learn maya's modeling and animation system. It's nothing special in design, but I figured it would be nice to start with something easy so I chose to animate a centaur. :P
First there is orientation alignment of bones. When you have for example three bones in the forearm (one for the elbow, two for the twist) you want them to be perfectly aligned. In max you could simply select a clild of the elbow and align it to the parent's orientation. Maya only seems to have a position alignment tool, and the orient constraint doesn't really do what I want it to either.
Here is an exaggerated look of three bones created in any viewport, as you can see they're not properly aligned on any axis.
After selecting each child and orienting it to its parent (and slightly rotating the elbow) you get this desired result in just a few clicks:
I've seen perfectly aligned shots of maya sleletons, just no way how to do this. This orientation alignment is somethin I used very often when rigging in max, so I really miss this feature.
I also haven't found any other helper/dummy alternatives to the locator. The locator probably works fine but it can only be displayed as a cross, which is a bitch to select and cripples a workflow. I've seen a lot of extremely fancy maya rigs, but was told these helpers were often nurbs caged rather than real helpers (which I don't care about by the way, I'm just looking for the best solution).
Whenever I bind a model to a skeleton using skin the bones all get coloured differently, no doubt according to their weight or place in the hierarchy. This isn't exactly the end of the world but it doesn't work as nice, and what's more annoying is that the colours remain the same after detaching the skin.
In MAX, for FK controls on single or double axis joints you had the ability to lock any axis so you won't accidentally break the elbow or fingers by selecting an axis that shouldn't be animatable.
Freezing objects is another thing in max I haven't found out about in maya. In max I could select any object and freeze it. It would still be visible, but couldn't be selected - which is great when animatnig with geometry on top.
I'm sure I've forgotten half the questions I had, which I will surely add to this post once they come up, but I'd also love to hear any of your own preferences, workflows and tips in order to create solid rigs. I also welcome any good tutorials. I've spend a good deal of time looking for maya tutorials, but they all focus on specific aspects or are so basic that they disregard having to actually use them in a stable animation environment.
I haven't had any serious problems with maya apart from the messy looking UI, and as expected the modeling features aren't as good as Max', which I read many times on forums. For as far as I have worked with the rigging / bone system, it did seem to be a lot more stable than Max, so I can't wait to get the aniamtion workflow down.
Thanks in advance,
Here is the model I created t learn maya's modeling and animation system. It's nothing special in design, but I figured it would be nice to start with something easy so I chose to animate a centaur. :P
First there is orientation alignment of bones. When you have for example three bones in the forearm (one for the elbow, two for the twist) you want them to be perfectly aligned. In max you could simply select a clild of the elbow and align it to the parent's orientation. Maya only seems to have a position alignment tool, and the orient constraint doesn't really do what I want it to either.
Here is an exaggerated look of three bones created in any viewport, as you can see they're not properly aligned on any axis.
After selecting each child and orienting it to its parent (and slightly rotating the elbow) you get this desired result in just a few clicks:
I've seen perfectly aligned shots of maya sleletons, just no way how to do this. This orientation alignment is somethin I used very often when rigging in max, so I really miss this feature.
I also haven't found any other helper/dummy alternatives to the locator. The locator probably works fine but it can only be displayed as a cross, which is a bitch to select and cripples a workflow. I've seen a lot of extremely fancy maya rigs, but was told these helpers were often nurbs caged rather than real helpers (which I don't care about by the way, I'm just looking for the best solution).
Whenever I bind a model to a skeleton using skin the bones all get coloured differently, no doubt according to their weight or place in the hierarchy. This isn't exactly the end of the world but it doesn't work as nice, and what's more annoying is that the colours remain the same after detaching the skin.
In MAX, for FK controls on single or double axis joints you had the ability to lock any axis so you won't accidentally break the elbow or fingers by selecting an axis that shouldn't be animatable.
Freezing objects is another thing in max I haven't found out about in maya. In max I could select any object and freeze it. It would still be visible, but couldn't be selected - which is great when animatnig with geometry on top.
I'm sure I've forgotten half the questions I had, which I will surely add to this post once they come up, but I'd also love to hear any of your own preferences, workflows and tips in order to create solid rigs. I also welcome any good tutorials. I've spend a good deal of time looking for maya tutorials, but they all focus on specific aspects or are so basic that they disregard having to actually use them in a stable animation environment.
I haven't had any serious problems with maya apart from the messy looking UI, and as expected the modeling features aren't as good as Max', which I read many times on forums. For as far as I have worked with the rigging / bone system, it did seem to be a lot more stable than Max, so I can't wait to get the aniamtion workflow down.
Thanks in advance,
Replies
As far as an align tool in Maya, can't help you there.
If you don't want anything more complex than locators, you can always set the selection hierarchy higher for locators in the Preferences, which should make them easier to grab if you did a marquee selection. It's in the Preferences-Selection Panel.
For the colored joints, go to the option box for smooth or rigid bind. There's a checkbox for colored joints you can check to off.
To lock a joint axis, go into the attribute editor for any joint. In the 'joint' category, right click on any field you want to lock and choose 'lock attribute'
For a freezing objects solution, you can create a new layer, assign all your geometry to the layer, then set your layer to 'R' (middle box). Anything set to R will be visible but unselectable.
Hope that helps.
[ QUOTE ]
For the colored joints, go to the option box for smooth or rigid bind. There's a checkbox for colored joints you can check to off.
[/ QUOTE ]
Is there also a way to revert the colors after you've done this? Simply reassigning the skin won't turn them back into blue bones.
[ QUOTE ]
To lock a joint axis, go into the attribute editor for any joint. In the 'joint' category, right click on any field you want to lock and choose 'lock attribute'
[/ QUOTE ]
All the 'stuff on the right' is a bit intimidating and seems to work completely different than how max handles everything.
Thanks again Funk, and to the rest, I'm still looking for a solution to the first problem I posted.
[ QUOTE ]
First there is orientation alignment of bones. When you have for example three bones in the forearm (one for the elbow, two for the twist) you want them to be perfectly aligned. In max you could simply select a clild of the elbow and align it to the parent's orientation. Maya only seems to have a position alignment tool, and the orient constraint doesn't really do what I want it to either.
[/ QUOTE ]
Select some bones and run this script to auto-align their axis (not sure if this is in the UI anywhere or not):
joint -e -oj xyz -zso -ch;
This sets the x-axis to go down the length of the bone, and sets the others to match down the chain. This is just a nice way to clean up the bones if you were fiddling with their placement.
Now, if you want to align some bones so that they are perfectly in line, open the attribute editor (ctrl-a is default) and make sure the rotate values are zero, and then under the Joint rollout, ensure the "Joint Orient" values are zero.
[ QUOTE ]
I also haven't found any other helper/dummy alternatives to the locator. The locator probably works fine but it can only be displayed as a cross, which is a bitch to select and cripples a workflow. I've seen a lot of extremely fancy maya rigs, but was told these helpers were often nurbs caged rather than real helpers (which I don't care about by the way, I'm just looking for the best solution).
[/ QUOTE ]
Personally, I hate fancy rigs with complex curves and shapes all over the place, it seems like riggers just doing something over-comlicated for the sake of it, but hey, whatever. (end personal rant).
Yes, you can use any type of node you want for helpers. Locators, curves, objects, whatever. Create a NURBS curve in whatever shape you want, that seems to be the most common thing.
[ QUOTE ]
Whenever I bind a model to a skeleton using skin the bones all get coloured differently, no doubt according to their weight or place in the hierarchy. This isn't exactly the end of the world but it doesn't work as nice, and what's more annoying is that the colours remain the same after detaching the skin.
[/ QUOTE ]
This is new in 7 and I haven't ha a look at it yet, but seems like one of those features people wanted (probably from some other package they liked it in). I think it can be turned off when binding. Just looking at it now, I can't see how to turn off the bone colours once they're set. Probably hidden away somewhere
[ QUOTE ]
In MAX, for FK controls on single or double axis joints you had the ability to lock any axis so you won't accidentally break the elbow or fingers by selecting an axis that shouldn't be animatable.
[/ QUOTE ]
Maya's default IK solver, the SC solver, keeps your joints in a plane if they already were. SO it will only ever bend the bone in the axis it was bent in when creating the chain. Now, if you have twist bones you don't want to rotate, you need to lock those channels. Click-drag on the channel name in the channel box to select the rotate channels, then right-click and choose "lock". now they won't rotate any more.
[ QUOTE ]
Freezing objects is another thing in max I haven't found out about in maya. In max I could select any object and freeze it. It would still be visible, but couldn't be selected - which is great when animatnig with geometry on top.
[/ QUOTE ]
Create a display layer, put stuff in it, set layer to "template" or "reference". Template is non-shaded and non-selectable, reference looks normal but can't be selected.
Skull, good to see you here again. I can't help you with the Maya stuff, but I would like to hear how you recovered from your case of RSI. It's pretty often we see threads about it here, but it's always good to hear another success story.
[/ QUOTE ]
Hey Rob. I can't say I'm all better again, but I can work properly again so it's just sticking to proper work routines and excersize from this point on. I went to a specialised doctor ('cesar-therapist') at first who gave me simple excersizes to help strengthen specific muscles and pointed me to how I should sit and work, though starting to do 3D work with a tablet so far has by far been the greatest help - especially since I got an intuos 3 A5 to replace my graphire A6.
Never had any problems and then it seemed to have hit me in a period of about a week, sucked.
Thanks a lot wharghoul!
That script didn't really seem to be of much good unless I applied it to a clean chain created into one of the orthographic viewports. otherwise it'd just mess with the orientation in an inconvienient way. The manually setting the rotational coordinates to 0 did work perfectly though.
As for rigs, I also keep them very clean and hate TD-showoff rigs. I do like to be able to easily select stuff such as an IK controller for the foot of the hips, as that is stuff you usually want to work with pretty fast, and such a locator simply is too small.
As far as thsoe 'locking angles', I was talking about FK, not IK. I know how IK works.
Thanks again for the detailed explenation!
Does anyone know if it's possible to move bones without affecting their children using the local (object) coordinate system? Using 'insert' (as in, the button on the keyboard) I can move bones without affecting, but only using the world coordinates. The way normal move mode is set doesn't affect how you can move bones using 'insert'.
Thanks in advance!
(the circle with a black dot in it) then move it
Once you have the Skeleton done, then comes the unmitigted joy of Rigging... which isn't.
Scott
Daz: Thanks for the link, lots of good stuff there.
Scott: Yeah, that's pretty much how I rigged in max as well, working in the perspective view's never a way to place anything accurately.