Home General Discussion

If you were to start a studio....

polycounter lvl 19
Offline / Send Message
poopinmymouth polycounter lvl 19
If you were part of a group starting up a studio, and you were in charge of setting up the art portion of the studio, what would be your top priority for the working environment? More time per asset? Better concepting? Giving the concepting to the production artists so they feel more involved? Really helpful tools and pipeline? A dedicated programmer to bring art tech online as needed?

Make a list of three things in the order of importance (one being the most important) of your top priorities in your ideal studio environment.

For me it would be:
1) Dedicated art programmer, purely for bringing on tech that the artists decide they want/need. (new shaders, full screen passes, exposed nodes, etc)
2) Consolidation of asset creation. While it might be less efficient, I think it's more fun and more cohesive to let each artist have as large a chunk of asset creation as possible. From concepting to implementation. Even if they might be slower at a certain portions of the pipeline, they will be more involved and take greater pride and ownership of the asset to bring it to a higher level of quality than when they get segmented to doing the specular map on the main characters toenails (as it seems the industry is heading).
3) Schedule dictated in conjunction with design. It seems too many studios go, "make all this level in a month" then the art manager decides what all needs making etc etc. I'd like to see the schedule and the asset list developed in tandem. This level could benefit from a three stage boss, so he will need three times the developement time as the other bosses, ok here is your timeline.

Runner up would be strong time tested tools. I really wanted to put that on the list, but ultimately the above three are more important to me personally.

What would yours be?

Replies

  • hawken
    Offline / Send Message
    hawken polycounter lvl 19
    1) hire a project manager/s that knows games not "knows games".
    2) make games in modules and link these modules together with people hired as "nodes"
    3) outsource modules
  • adam
    Offline / Send Message
    adam polycounter lvl 19
    I personally love the idea of small teams developing and publishing their own games. Albeit, I know this can be extremely hard to do, but with new applications coming out - like Steam - this is becoming more and more easier.


    Now as for the art side of production directly:

    1.) I agree on having a programmer specifically concentrate on art. Listening to the artists and their needs, the implementing them within the specified engine. Having this kind of curtesy would be very helpful, I feel.

    2.) This goes back to my feelings of smaller development teams. I'm again with you on "consolidation of asset creation" - being able to take actual OWNERSHIP in the work you create I feel is ideal to any artist. You could be Worker X working at a larger company. I have a feeling you'd feel more like guy putting the heads on the dolls at the factory, or the monkey on the typewriter, rather than the artist designing the work from beginning to end. That sense and feeling of ownership is something special, and companies need to be more open to this idea. I wouldn't last long at a company if I was sitting there doing specular masks all day.

    3.) Thirdly, I'd have to say the overall atmosphere of the office would have to be important. Us, as developers, have a certain business culture that's unique - and I'd love to exploit that if I ever had my own office. Things like no dress code (well, don't come nude) and/or free lunches & drinks anytime are important. If the artist/programmer can come to work COMPLETELY COMFORTABLE then that'll leave a lot of their brain power to the art/work at hand, and not concentrating on their trousers being wrinkled.

    One thing that I'd like to mention aswell is having the company budgeting for monthly/bi-monthly outtings. Now, with a small team this is ideal as you don't have to budget a lot (or as much) money if you were to do this with a larger (50+) team. Things like sky diving, white-water rafting, paintball, etc would all be things on this budget. Putting your team in another team environment OUTSIDE of creating videogames is a good exercise I feel any company should do (hell, McDonald's does it).

    Good thread Ben.
  • MoP
    Offline / Send Message
    MoP polycounter lvl 18
    Personally I don't agree with the "consolidation" thing, unless you're talking about having one guy concepting->modelling->texturing characters, one guy doing the same for weapons, and another for props or whatever.
    Here's what I reckon (bear in mind this is probably from a horribly uninformed and misguided standpoint smile.gif ) :

    1) For a more coherent overall game I'd have one dedicated AWESOME concept artist (not necessarily an ultra-fine draftsman - just a fellow with good drawing/communication skills and great ideas) ... they would set up the designs for everything in the game - characters, monsters, vehicles, environments, weapons ... basically they'd have a boatload of work, but it'd be scheduled in such a way as to make it feasible.
    That way everything would have a consistent "feel" throughout the game.

    2) Dedicated art programmer is a great idea, I'd have one of those!

    3) What AdamBrome said about working environment is a good one. I'd only hire people i could really rely on, and know they'd work and get on well together.

    I probably missed a whole bunch of important stuff, but hey, this is hypothetical, and I'm only 20 wink.gif

    MoP
  • Weiser_Cain
    Offline / Send Message
    Weiser_Cain polycounter lvl 18
    Keep in mind I know nothing.

    Get the concepts as tight as possible.
    Make the schedule off of that.
    Then just keep going till it's done. I hate half finished projects.
  • Jay Evans
    Offline / Send Message
    Jay Evans polycounter lvl 18
    -tools that work... all the time
    -simplicity of workflow. The less time you spend jumping through hoops to export\troubleshoot and the more time you can spend in the "creation" stage the better, I think.

    -and of course: nice enviroment\ team ect. ect.
  • JO420
    Offline / Send Message
    JO420 polycounter lvl 18
    I would have to say a good company culture and work environment which promotes creativity and innovation.

    a good work environment is very very important,you make a work environment that makes people want to come to work you will get the best out of people,less turnover and overall a desire for sucess from all your workers.
  • ElysiumGX
    Offline / Send Message
    ElysiumGX polycounter lvl 18
    1. Develope a software pipeline that prevents broken or corrupt assets and remains compatible with preferred exchange formats for better transitions between artists' software choices.

    2. Hire a staff that's more focused on creating fun, visually pleasing assets for games than earning large paychecks. Set loose reasonable deadlines so artists have time to expand their abilities.

    3. Build a bridge of communication between 2D artists, 3D artists, and programmers, allowing them to work very closely together with a collectively understandable vocabulary and knowledge of each skill.
  • ryan77
    Offline / Send Message
    ryan77 polycounter lvl 18
    BEN I WANT TO LIVE ON YOUR TEAM
  • oXYnary
    Offline / Send Message
    oXYnary polycounter lvl 18
    <ul type="square">[*]Co-Op/Employee owned. Give employees ownership, and they will put everything into it.
    [*]Managers who really manage,and realize people DO NOT give more output on tight schedules and long hours. Who also are willing to take responsibility for their own mismanagement. To this end anonymous questionaires are given to the employees under each manager every month where it can be shown where each manager is and team moral.
    [*]Hourly Wages for everyone.
    [*]Less formal chain of command. Marxism has been shown to work in smaller businesses and institutions. This however, does NOT mean multiple people have to approve someones work. Or having more than 1 "upper" tell an artist two different things.
    [*]Recognition of Game Designers. The Game Designers are promoted along with the game. Sorta like American Mcgee was trying to promote. This would fuck over publishers who can buy up franchises. They cant buy up the Designer, and people will see this.
    [*]As Per Poops excellent idea, Artist can contribute to all areas of art design versus just being stuck in one small area. This would require a very detailed art design document so all artist have a good basis to go around versus relying on a few concept artists.[/list]
  • pogonip
    Offline / Send Message
    pogonip polycounter lvl 18
    1: Hire game designer with ambitions and vision beyond creating FPS and MMPG #76876 , also a producer who has a track record for working hard and making good desisions and stand up to coperate types who are demanding shoter deadlines and other BS.

    2:Hire people to do certain jobs who are very good at certain tasks . I know it might be more fun to be a jack of all trades but it's also hard to be really good at everything . In this area I would have Texture artists who are master painters, modelers who can sculpt anything , and concept artists who are given the time to work side by side with the designer and given enough freedom to bring about very unique vision . I'd probebly go with concept artists who have a long track record in comics or illustration. I personally think this is the most important person on the art team . Imagine you went to work on Dinotopia and you had all those books and great artwork to go off of . That is the kind of Art Bible & Design Bible I would want to be created .

    3) Make sure the game had proper development time . Try and foster the mentality to the bean counters that better game = bigger profits . That coupled with a good amount of advertising would hopefully be a sure win .


    Could make a lot bigger list then 3 smile.gif
  • oXYnary
    Offline / Send Message
    oXYnary polycounter lvl 18
    fuck didnt realize it was three only.. well combine some of mine since they kinda overlap smile.gif.
  • flaagan
    Offline / Send Message
    flaagan polycounter lvl 18
    couple things i can think of based off of work i've done on mods and whatnot
    - coders that are dedicated to getting the job done, and will talk with the artists on a constant, friendly basis, in order to get both groups thinking about the best solutions to graphical and design issues
    - organizing a pipeline beforehand, not partway through, the process
    - have the QA on the same floor, possibly even the same room, as the devs, because QA needs to be listened to... they are supposed to be a representative of your target audience
  • Ramucho
    Offline / Send Message
    Ramucho polycounter lvl 18
    I'd hire Bobo, Daz, Soul, Pior, Poop, Shimmer, Peppy, Per128, Strangefate, Mop, Hawkprey, djurdjevic, mojo, brome and EQ for the fun

    And then we'll kick ass! smile.gif
  • MoP
    Offline / Send Message
    MoP polycounter lvl 18
    I wouldn't work with that Per guy... he's such a bastard!
  • PaK
    Offline / Send Message
    PaK polycounter lvl 18
    I'd like to have what i got honestly:

    -A talented, responsive and accomedating code staff that work with the content creators. Everyone helpuing everyone else as opposed to any one side being the others' bitch

    -Asset pipelines that are clean, ratified, and monitored by a dedicated tech artist.

    -Give developers 1 person to report to. Several layers of managment that interact with the deveklopers directly is not my idea of a good studio structure.

    -Create a senior/apprentice relationship with the newbs/interns

    -promote leads from within the studio. Put them through leadership workshops. Promote leads who are honest and patient, not whatever it is I've had to deal throughout my career until now (aside from Bodyrott ofocurse smile.gif

    Leadership is key...if you don't have good leaders you're screwed. leaders promote the corp culture and set the tone for the behavior.

    -Smash smack talk down the moment it starts. (no laughing at me for suggesting that)

    -R
  • Kevin Johnstone
    Offline / Send Message
    Kevin Johnstone polycounter lvl 19
    1. Secure massive amounts of money as funding
    2. Register chapter 7 once have money
    3. Retire to lifetime of painting castles and landscapes smile.gif

    r.
  • rawkstar
    Offline / Send Message
    rawkstar polycounter lvl 19
    I'd hire Pak, Ramucho, oXYnary, pogonip, mishra, warhead, John_Warner, Weiser_Cain, and shotgun smile.gif
    i'd have shotgun do art and then the rest will get paid to post entertaining stuff on polycount.
  • John Warner
    Offline / Send Message
    John Warner polycounter lvl 18
    ooohhhhhh the love. i can feel it.
  • Weiser_Cain
    Offline / Send Message
    Weiser_Cain polycounter lvl 18
    What's smackdown talk? And why isn't anyone pretend-hireing me?
  • pogonip
    Offline / Send Message
    pogonip polycounter lvl 18
    [ QUOTE ]
    I'd hire Pak, Ramucho, oXYnary, pogonip, mishra, warhead, John_Warner, Weiser_Cain, and shotgun smile.gif
    i'd have shotgun do art and then the rest will get paid to post entertaining stuff on polycount.

    [/ QUOTE ]

    That's not right tongue.gif
  • PaK
    Offline / Send Message
    PaK polycounter lvl 18
    I'd consider it...but i have a few.....quesssstions:

    -Do I get to share a cube with John?

    -How many warnings do I get before I get fired for playing tricks on oxy and nipple slip?

    -I hear it gets hot in Texas. Will you pay for a air purifier for my cube? If not, then will you pay my lawyer fee's if said federal governmnet considers steamed PaK a chemical weapon of mass destruction? at least get me a corner room with a window at gitmo with a view of some cuban hotties or...something.

    -R
  • hawken
    Offline / Send Message
    hawken polycounter lvl 19
    give employees freedom on loose deadlines and they will do jack shit.

    have a nice working environment, and when you can't afford that anymore the employees will be grumpy.

    make the company a co-op and the employees will splinter into factions.

    make me a cup of tea and I'll give you a biscuit.
  • hawken
    Offline / Send Message
    hawken polycounter lvl 19
    oh and hire artists that actually listen to the art director, instead of going off on one and ending up with useless assets. (from experience frown.gif)
  • Daz
    Offline / Send Message
    Daz polycounter lvl 18
    Depends wether or not the AD is respectworthy and knows what he's talking about. There are a lot of AD's in this bizz that are totally useless imo. There are some goodn's tho. But listening to him blindly without question just 'cos he's the AD? Nah ( from experience ). If we did that on our team we'd never fit the game into bloody memory. All AD's where I work are from film you see and know little about making videogames.

    Quality of people is the numero uno factor in building a studio. Without that nothing else matters. It still blows me away how many studios don't get that.
  • joolz8000
    Offline / Send Message
    joolz8000 polycounter lvl 18
    I'd like to see more collaboration between concept artists and production artists, from inception to completion. So often I see concepts that just won't work, or that were ALMOST really cool, and other times I see finished work that sucks because the artists didn't quite 'get' the concept. Just more communication would be swell. I'm sure this happens in the better production houses... right?
  • oXYnary
    Offline / Send Message
    oXYnary polycounter lvl 18
    [ QUOTE ]
    make the company a co-op and the employees will splinter into factions.

    [/ QUOTE ]

    Proof please?
  • hawken
    Offline / Send Message
    hawken polycounter lvl 19
    DAZ: I was thinking about projects when you're really trying to break the mold and do something new, keeping focused on such a tight design is really hard when artists decide to ignore that and do a poo all over the screen. "I thought your radical idea was too strange and made a ford transit instead of the batmobile."
    (It's enough to have people around you asking why we can't just play it safe.)

    oXYnary:Yeah like I'm gonna list the company politics I know here. Do your homework by yourself.
  • Daz
    Offline / Send Message
    Daz polycounter lvl 18
    Ah right I getcha. I thought you meant in terms of the intricate details of the task at hand. They're actually pretty strict about 'doing what the AD says' where I work. You just have to take it with a pinch of salt for reasons I mentioned. If you're talking about Artistic discipline too though, you can't beat the Japanese studios for that. Take a game like MGS2 where every texture map looks like it was painted by one artist. I wonder what their secret is for maintaing that kind of discipline?
  • oXYnary
    Offline / Send Message
    oXYnary polycounter lvl 18
    I have, and I do my shopping and banking at co-ops. So I would appreciate some counter points to ponder versus just saying it doesn't work, and it will end in factions.

    What is considered a co-op to you? Questions like: You are speaking about Japanese versions? Do they have the same regulations as other countries? How big are they in Japan? Are you specifically speaking of game co-ops?
  • hawken
    Offline / Send Message
    hawken polycounter lvl 19
    Daz: I'd say that Japanese games are probably my favorites if push comes to shove. I'm not sure how they do it, but from my experience it often involves a large beating stick and lack of sleep.
  • flaagan
    Offline / Send Message
    flaagan polycounter lvl 18
    ok, it had to be said at some point...
    Step 1) Get a game idea
    Step 2) . . .
    Step 3) Profit!
Sign In or Register to comment.