Home Technical Talk
The BRAWL² Tournament Challenge has been announced!

It starts May 12, and ends Oct 17. Let's see what you got!

https://polycount.com/discussion/237047/the-brawl²-tournament

How to solve this baking issue?

(My English is not very good)…When performing hard surface normal baking, this issue often arises: strange fine ridges appear along the low-poly topology. How to fix it?


Replies

  • Eric Chadwick
    What do the UVs look like? Are those seams on UV splits, and if so did you add padding there?

    What tool
    are you baking with? What tool are you rendering in? What file formats are you using? What bit depth is the normal map?
  • Neox
    Offline / Send Message
    Neox grand marshal polycounter
    The issue with this is, too little texture space to compensate for too much shading. Basically you have very strong low poly shading going on. The normalmap tries to compensate but there aren't enough pixels (or bit depth 16bit vs 8bit) to cover it. 

    You have 2 options basically

    Upping the texture resolution and possibly bit depth 

    Or 

    Reducing the lowpoly shading

    I would opt for the latter, get rid of the long thin triangles. Use some more geo or custom normals to flatten what the normal map has to compensate

    Just look at the lowpoly without any normalmap, all that strong smooth shading is what the normalmap needs to carry, help it a bit :)
  • WangQiang
    Eric Chadwick, Thank you for your response. The cyan edges in the image represent the hard edges and UV seams. I baked the texture using Marmoset Toolbag, and the issue appears both in Marmoset Toolbag and Substance Painter. As Neox mentioned, I tried it, and it is indeed due to the texture space being too small.
  • WangQiang
    Neox said:
    The issue with this is, too little texture space to compensate for too much shading. Basically you have very strong low poly shading going on. The normalmap tries to compensate but there aren't enough pixels (or bit depth 16bit vs 8bit) to cover it. 

    You have 2 options basically

    Upping the texture resolution and possibly bit depth 

    Or 

    Reducing the lowpoly shading

    I would opt for the latter, get rid of the long thin triangles. Use some more geo or custom normals to flatten what the normal map has to compensate

    Just look at the lowpoly without any normalmap, all that strong smooth shading is what the normalmap needs to carry, help it a bit :)
    You've been a huge help. That was indeed the reason, and the issue has been resolved. Thank you so much.
Sign In or Register to comment.