Personal M4 Carbine. WORK IN PROGRESS. Would like Critique and Constructive Criticism

Michael_WorkAccount · Feb 2018

Model/Wireframe:

Image: https://us.v-cdn.net/5021068/uploads/editor/z7/zxptxs3t9kzc.png

First Pass Texture:

Image: https://us.v-cdn.net/5021068/uploads/editor/nl/6btcumnq6lxg.png

Sketchfab Model(So you can rotate):
https://sketchfab.com/models/78dfad5faf4c4aa0a61780c9e0b55c84

Rotation Gif:
Attached gif file

Current Render:

Image: https://us.v-cdn.net/5021068/uploads/editor/9h/cbrt7z9jhsp8.png

Image: https://us.v-cdn.net/5021068/uploads/editor/l5/y2j04drtdyj0.png

CrackRockSteady · Feb 2018

Looks like a really solid start.

Probably the most obvious thing that stands out as soon as I look at your wireframe is that you have a lot of unnecessary geo. Pretty much anywhere you have edge loops that don't change the silhouette or are needed for smoothing can be removed/welded.

jaker3278 · Feb 2018

Did you use a normal map for this model? The hand grip looks very sharp on the edges as does the magazine. I would work on this for your next project. On the whole well done ,you got the detail in and the shapes down, now you just need to implement some new techniques to your work flow to get even better.

Amsterdam Hilton Hotel · Feb 2018

Good effort man, here are some critiques

Image: https://us.v-cdn.net/5021068/uploads/editor/eh/bik4sohf8tfl.jpg

Michael_WorkAccount · Feb 2018

Thank you so much for all of the responses! They really helped. I did use a normal and the grip has a few too little polygons. I will get to work on all the things that you mentioned

slosh · Feb 2018

I would say localize your dirt and wear more. Add it where it would make sense. Have some spec breakup but you don't need dirt and damage everywhere. Add nice edgewear instead.

Michael_WorkAccount · Feb 2018

CrackRockSteady said:

Looks like a really solid start.

Probably the most obvious thing that stands out as soon as I look at your wireframe is that you have a lot of unnecessary geo. Pretty much anywhere you have edge loops that don't change the silhouette or are needed for smoothing can be removed/welded.

I try to keep things clean and easy to manipulate, which unfortunately creates some unnecessary geometry. I did, however, keep the model to under 12K polygons. After reading your response, I have gone through the mesh and deleted any edges that don't serve any visual or UV purposes.

jaker3278 said:

Did you use a normal map for this model? The hand grip looks very sharp on the edges as does the magazine. I would work on this for your next project. On the whole well done ,you got the detail in and the shapes down, now you just need to implement some new techniques to your work flow to get even better.

Yes there is a normal and a height map. However, the hand grip is quite low poly . I was able to shift the UV map so that I can smooth the edges of the mesh. Thank you for the response and I will work more on the edge flow for my next project.

Amsterdam Hilton Hotel said:

Good effort man, here are some critiques

The image and details are VERY useful. I appreciate the effort highly. Some of the critiques have already been fixed(as seen inn the current render) but I am thankful that you caught them and for the advice. I have taken the time to go through each of the critiques and make changes based on them.

Personal M4 Carbine. WORK IN PROGRESS. Would like Critique and Constructive Criticism

Replies