Mental Ray for Normal Maps?

Jessica Dinh · Nov 2010

I know you're supposed to use mental ray for rendering ambient occlusion maps. But do you use mental ray for rendering normal maps, or do you use the default scanline renderer?

glynnsmith · Nov 2010

I'd guess you're using Max?

I use the scanline renderer for both normals and AO. It's quicker for me to set up, it's quicker at rendering, and it usually yields better results.

wannabeartist · Nov 2010

Yes you can (Max). It makes no difference, afaik.

I used both, but then I switched to xNormal.

Jessica Dinh · Nov 2010

Oh ok, thanks! Good to know I could technically use either one.

Eric Chadwick · Nov 2010

Lots about AO methods here on the wiki
http://wiki.polycount.com/AmbientOcclusionMap

r_fletch_r · Nov 2010

+1 to Glynn with exception to the AO maps. MR does very nice AO. it may take a little longer but you get much finer control over the final map. With MR's ambient occlusion you can set a maximum distance value which essentially lets you control the distance at which a ray hit wont cause occlusion. this is great when using floaters. you simply set the max distance and ensure that your floaters are above that height. Max distance is also really important if you want to create a cavity map as you can just restrict the shading to small crevices

Snight · Nov 2010

I agree with fletch. I'm a recent converter to mR AO maps.The results are much nicer in my opinion and you get much better control.

glynnsmith · Nov 2010

Hmmm. Can you guys give some examples of settings, for me to try out? I do like the idea of using Mental Ray, but I find the simplicity and quickness of the scanline to trump it.

But it'll all be in the settings, no doubt.

Eric Chadwick · Nov 2010

Xoliul has some settings here
http://www.laurenscorijn.com/articles/ambient-occlusion-baking

Ott · Nov 2010

I've written a couple tutorials on how to set it up, depending on which version of 3dsMax you are using. In 2011 it's extremely simple and only requires a couple clicks:

http://donott-lcad.blogspot.com/2009/09/mental-ray-ambient-occlusion.html

I've actually noticed that with 2011 it seems to be a lot smarter about having overlapped or inverted faces than it used to be. Whether baking normals or AO, 2011 seems to let you have inverted or overlapped faces without error so long as they are symmetrical UV sets without the need to move them outside of the 0,1 space.

glynnsmith · Nov 2010

Thanks Eric

OTT, I'm a Max 2009 user, so I'm not sure if it'll translate all that well, if it's more geared to 2011. But I shall have a look. Cheers

r_fletch_r · Nov 2010

should work just fine. I'm pretty sure i was using it in 2009 before i moved to 2011. mib_ambient/reflective occlusion is definately available in 2009

Ott · Nov 2010

I have a second tutorial listed there for Mental Ray AO for previous versions other than 2011. I updated the post because the features are slightly different, and that is the version I am teaching in my class

Let me know if I miss a step, over-complicate anything, or anything is "wrong", because its the same methods I have used for years as well

Undren · Nov 2010

Great tutorials, Ott! These help a lot!

Mental Ray for Normal Maps?

Replies