3ds Max: edge extrude with local pivot

SuperFranky · Sep 2014

I'm trying to extrude edge using Shift+Drag with a local coordinate reference system, but for some reason it doesn't work. I keep dragging, but the extruded edge doesn't move in needed direction. Is there something I do wrong or there's another way to do that?

I made a video of it https://www.dropbox.com/s/3jrwt8nki0c4nc2/bandicam%202014-09-03%2023-01-02-472.avi?dl=0 .

miauu · Sep 2014

The same situation here. Did you noticed that as soon as you hold down Shift key and press the Axis tripot the Orientation of the tripod is changed - the Z axis points in different direction than when the shift key is not pressed?

SuperFranky · Sep 2014

miauu wrote: »

The same situation here. Did you noticed that as soon as you hold down Shift key and press the Axis tripot the Orientation of the tripod is changed - the Z axis points in different direction than when the shift key is not pressed?

yep, it works as you describe. It seems that the edge is being extruded when you click on it, but goes nowhere after that or not in the direction you need.

instg8r · Sep 2014

That seemed to be broken for me as well in 2014. My fix was to just extrude it a very small amount in world space, then I was able to use local to extend it out further...Crappy for sure. I also ran into issues with my Gizmo becoming "distorted". Local extrude is working as intended in Max 2015, though!

SuperFranky · Sep 2014

instg8r wrote: »

That seemed to be broken for me as well in 2014. My fix was to just extrude it a very small amount in world space, then I was able to use local to extend it out further...Crappy for sure. I also ran into issues with my Gizmo becoming "distorted". Local extrude is working as intended in Max 2015, though!

Oh, I guess it's time to update 3ds Max

SpaceJunkee · Sep 2014

Try Parent instead local.. that works sometimes.

miauu · Sep 2014

SuperFranky wrote: »

yep, it works as you describe. It seems that the edge is being extruded when you click on it, but goes nowhere after that or not in the direction you need.

I can confirm. On max2015 edge extrude on local axis works properly, on max2014 - not.

SuperFranky · Sep 2014

miauu wrote: »

I can confirm. On max2015 edge extrude on local axis works properly, on max2014 - not.

It's always the same with these annual updates, they always break something:snarl:

j_bradford · Sep 2014

I've never really liked Max's local extrude, works accurately for me about half the time. I would recommend Illusioncatalyt's extendsurface script, been using it for years in production and it's a good alternative to max's if doesn't give you the desired results.

http://www.illusioncatalyst.com/ic_scripts/ic_extend_surface.php

SuperFranky · Sep 2014

j_bradford wrote: »

I've never really liked Max's local extrude, works accurately for me about half the time. I would recommend Illusioncatalyt's extendsurface script, been using it for years in production and it's a good alternative to max's if doesn't give you the desired results.

http://www.illusioncatalyst.com/ic_scripts/ic_extend_surface.php

Thanks, that will come in handy.

pablohotsauce · Sep 2014

You can also try Chris Whitaker's FB Sub-Obj Pivot plugin:
http://www.funkybunnies3d.com/tools.php

SuperFranky · Sep 2014

pableaux wrote: »

You can also try Chris Whitaker's FB Sub-Obj Pivot plugin:
http://www.funkybunnies3d.com/tools.php

Thanks, I already discovered it on my own, it's really helpful.

3ds Max: edge extrude with local pivot

Replies